Installment Sales Trust (IST)™
A Strategic Alternative to the 1031 Exchange
Do you want to exit highly appreciated real estate without being locked into the 1031 exchange cycle?
Would you prefer flexibility in how sale proceeds are invested and integrated into your broader estate and tax planning rather than being forced to acquire another “like-kind” property under strict IRS deadlines?
An Installment Sales Trust (IST)™ may provide an alternative legal strategy for deferring capital gains taxes on the sale of appreciated commercial or residential real estate while allowing for greater planning flexibility and risk management.
The Limitations of the Traditional 1031 Exchange
Many real estate owners are familiar with the 1031 exchange as the primary method for deferring capital gains taxes. While effective in certain circumstances, a 1031 exchange requires:
- Identification of replacement property within 45 days
- Closing within 180 days
- Reinvestment exclusively into like-kind real estate
- Continued exposure to real estate market and management risk
For some sellers, these constraints limit liquidity, diversification, and long-term planning options.
Legal Foundation of the Installment Sales Trust
The Installment Sales Trust is grounded in the federal installment sale rules under Internal Revenue Code § 453, which permit capital gains taxes to be deferred when sale proceeds are received over time rather than in a single lump sum. Under § 453, capital gain is generally recognized proportionately as installment payments are received, allowing the seller to spread tax liability over multiple years, subject to proper structuring and compliance.
Traditional Installment Sale vs. Installment Sales Trust
In a traditional installment sale, the buyer pays the seller directly over time pursuant to an installment note. While this defers capital gains taxes, it exposes the seller to significant buyer-related risks, including default, insolvency, or bankruptcy. Enforcement options may be limited and costly.
An Installment Sales Trust (IST)™ replaces reliance on the buyer with a third-party trust structure, providing additional safeguards and greater planning flexibility.
How an Installment Sales Trust (IST)™ Works
An IST™ is typically structured as follows:
- The property is sold to an unrelated third-party buyer.
- Sale proceeds are transferred to an independent trust.
- The trust issues an installment note to the seller.
- The trust makes scheduled installment payments over time.
- Trust assets may be invested in accordance with an agreed-upon strategy.
The IST™ can be customized to address payment timing, duration, and coordination with estate planning objectives. Throughout the life of the trust, legal, tax, and financial professionals work together to help ensure proper administration and compliance.
Comparison of Common Strategies
Feature | 1031 Exchange | Traditional Installment Sale | Installment Sales Trust (IST)™ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Capital gains tax deferral | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Reinvestment required | Real estate only | No | No |
| Buyer credit risk | N/A | High | Mitigated through trust |
| Liquidity | Limited | Limited | Greater flexibility |
| Investment diversification | No | No | Possible |
| IRS timing restrictions | Strict | None | None |
| Estate planning integration | Limited | Limited | High |
Estate and Legacy Planning Considerations
An Installment Sales Trust is often evaluated in conjunction with broader estate planning strategies, including revocable trusts, dynasty trusts, asset protection planning, and intergenerational wealth transfer.
In many cases, the installment note may pass to beneficiaries at death and—depending on overall estate planning and applicable tax law—may reduce or eliminate future estate tax exposure.
Who May Benefit From an Installment Sales Trust™
An IST™ may be appropriate for individuals who:
- Own highly appreciated commercial or residential real estate
- Wish to defer capital gains taxes without reinvesting in real estate
- Are concerned about buyer default in a traditional installment sale
- Seek to integrate real estate exits into long-term estate planning
An IST™ is not appropriate for every transaction and should be evaluated on a case-by-case basis.
Important Legal Disclosure
This content is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal or tax advice. Installment Sales Trusts involve complex legal and tax considerations and are not suitable for all transactions. Tax treatment depends on individual circumstances, proper structuring, and ongoing compliance. Consultation with qualified legal, tax, and financial advisors is required.
Request an Installment Sales Trust Review
J.S. Burton, P.L.C. provides legal analysis and structuring of Installment Sales Trusts in coordination with tax and financial advisors.
Contact our office to determine whether an IST™ is appropriate for your real estate transaction and estate planning objectives.
Opinions That Matter Most
Read What Our Former Clients Have to Say
-
"Prompt, Professional, Courteous, Concerned and Caring"- Bill O.
-
"If you're looking for trustworthy and skilled professionals for your estate planning, look no further!"I recently had the pleasure of working with Fallon Whidden from the JSBurton Law Firm for my estate planning needs, and I cannot recommend them highly enough!- Tamara C.
-
"I give them a 5* plus! Honest, Reliable, and Caring!"John Burton is the best and most honest that I have found. You can rely on him for all your needs. Once you have spoken to him, you won't be going anywhere else.- Richard K.
-
"We highly recommend them"We recently had our Living Trust prepared by Fallon at JS Burton, PLC and they did an excellent job. Everything was explained in great detail and Fallon was awesome to work with! We highly recommend them for estate planning services.- Paul H.
-
"An excellent estate planning attorney"Mr. Burton, Esq. is an excellent estate planning attorney and I recommend him with a 5 star rating. He is patient and answers all questions. His organization of the plan that he provided was in a binder and very complete.- Jeffrey S.
-
"Very professional, friendly, thoughtful, and highly knowledgeable, Fallon expedited preparation and delivery of my documents. Overall, this was an awesome experience"
I just had a great experience with this firm in preparing my estate planning documents. I needed to update some wishes and also ensure everything is in line for the state of Virginia, as I moved here from Pennsylvania. I worked with Fallon Francesca Whi
- Wendy V. -
"I would highly recommend him."I have met with Mr Burton several times and always found him to be professional and personable- Bonnie T.
-
"Highly recommended for estate planning"We were heard and guided to do the best for our families needs- Fred S.